To The Highest Standards
Schedule a Free Consultation Today
When Can a Failed Dental Implant Be Grounds for a Lawsuit?
Dental implants work well for most people. The American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons puts their overall success rate at about 95 percent. Unfortunately, that high success rate still leaves a number of patients who end up with a loose implant, an infection, nerve pain, or a mouth that needs more surgery to fix.
Some of those failures happen even when the dentist did everything right. Others happen because a step was skipped or a warning sign was ignored. A Maryland dental malpractice attorney can help you tell the difference, and that difference is what decides whether you have a case.
Key Takeaways
A failed implant isn’t automatically someone’s fault. Implants sometimes fail even when the dentist does everything right. You may have a case if the dentist made a mistake a careful provider wouldn’t have made, and that mistake caused your injury.
Signs of malpractice often appear before or right after surgery. Watch for skipped X-rays or scans, a health history that never came up, numbness that doesn’t go away, or pain and swelling that your dentist brushed off. Not being told about a serious risk ahead of time can also be grounds for a claim.
Be aware of the time limits for filing your claim. In Maryland, you generally have three years from when you discovered the problem to bring a claim. No matter what, you can’t file more than five years after the injury. A dental expert also has to back your claim early in the process, so it’s best not to wait.
When a Failed Implant Is Malpractice
Implants can fail for reasons no one controls. Sometimes the jawbone simply doesn’t fuse with the implant, even with careful planning. Smoking, uncontrolled diabetes, and slow healing all raise the risk, which is why the FDA encourages patients to talk with their provider about the benefits, risks, and whether they are a good candidate before treatment.
To bring a malpractice claim, you have to show that the dentist or oral surgeon fell below the standard of care. That means they did something a reasonably careful provider in the same field would not have done, or failed to do something they should have. You also have to show that this mistake caused your injury. A bad result alone is not enough.
Situations That Often Point to Negligence
Attorneys who review these claims look closely at the planning stage, because that is where many preventable failures start. Common problems include:
Skipping proper imaging. Placing an implant without adequate X-rays or 3D scans can lead to the implant hitting a nerve, entering the sinus, or being set in bone too thin to hold it.
Ignoring health risks. A provider who doesn’t review your medical history, or who places an implant despite active gum disease or uncontrolled diabetes without addressing it first, may have cut corners.
Poor placement. An implant set at the wrong angle or depth, or too close to a neighboring tooth, can fail or damage the structures around it.
Nerve damage. Lasting numbness, tingling, or burning in the lip, chin, or tongue after lower jaw implant surgery may mean the drill or implant injured a nerve.
Missed infection. Pain, swelling, and drainage after surgery call for prompt treatment. A provider who brushes off these signs can turn a fixable problem into bone loss.
No informed consent. Maryland requires providers to explain the material risks and alternatives a reasonable patient would want to know before agreeing to treatment. If a serious, known risk was never disclosed and it happened to you, that can support a claim on its own.
What Maryland Requires Before a Lawsuit
Maryland has a specific process for health care malpractice claims, and it applies to dentists. Most claims must start with the Health Care Alternative Dispute Resolution Office instead of in court. Within 90 days of filing, the claimant generally must file a Certificate of Qualified Expert, along with the expert’s report, stating that the provider departed from the standard of care and that this caused the injury (Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 3-2A-04). The case usually moves to circuit court after arbitration is waived.
This is where many dental cases rise or fall. The expert generally must have training and experience in the same or a related field as the provider being sued, and Maryland law limits how much of their professional time can go to testifying. Finding a qualified oral surgeon or periodontist willing to review your records takes time, which is one reason attorneys want to get involved early.
Deadlines are strict. Under Md. Code, Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 5-109, a claim must be filed within five years of the injury or three years from when it was discovered, whichever comes first. Implant problems can take months to show up, but the five-year outer limit still applies.
Factors That Can Affect Your Case
Maryland is one of the few states that still follows contributory negligence. If a jury finds that you contributed to your own injury in any way, you may be barred from recovering at all. In implant cases, the defense often points to smoking, missed follow-up visits, or not following post-surgery instructions. Your attorney will want to know your full history, including the parts that seem unhelpful, so they can prepare for these arguments.
Damages also have limits. For injuries that occur in 2026, Maryland caps noneconomic damages in health care malpractice cases at $920,000. Economic losses, like the cost of corrective surgery, replacement implants, and lost income, are not capped. Fixing a failed implant can involve removal, bone grafting, and new restorations, so documenting every cost matters.
Steps You Can Take Now
If you think your implant failed because of a provider’s mistake:
Request a full copy of your dental records, including X-rays, scans, and treatment notes.
Get a second opinion from a different dentist or oral surgeon, and ask them to put their findings in writing.
Keep receipts, insurance statements, and a simple log of symptoms like pain or numbness.
Avoid discussing fault with the original provider or signing anything that releases claims.
You can also file a complaint with the Maryland State Board of Dental Examiners. The Board can investigate and discipline a licensed dentist, but it does not handle fee disputes or refund requests, and it cannot award you compensation. A malpractice claim is the path to recovering your losses.
Talk With a Lawyer About Your Implant
A failed implant can mean months of pain, extra surgery, and thousands of dollars in costs you never planned for. The attorneys at the Law Offices of Fred B. Goldberg, PC review dental records, work with qualified experts, and handle Maryland’s pre-suit requirements so injured patients can focus on getting their health back.
If your dental implant failed and you suspect something went wrong, contact the firm today to schedule a consultation. They can review what happened and help you decide whether your claim is worth pursuing.
RECENT POSTS
You went to the dentist for treatment but left with a broken tooth and the prospect of additional dental bills. Now you may need a crown, root canal, or extraction for an unexpected injury.